Roll Call
Special Presentation to conclude at 1:00 p.m.* a) Introduction of the consulting team for “Resilient Heritage in the Nation’s Oldest City” grant to include discussion and public comment
Approval of Minutes
Modification and approval of Agenda
Recommended Expedited Hearing Items a) Certificate of Appropriateness Paul J. Thompson – Applicant and Owner 2019-0104 168 Avenida Menendez To construct a 5’ masonry and stucco property wall with wood gate and relocate existing fencing to the second floor balcony. b) Certificate of Appropriateness John Valdes and Associates, Inc. - Applicant 2019-0107 Gary and Laura Shivers – Owner 101 Marine Street To alter a portion of the rear, northeast corner of the building’s first floor to include windows, doors, roofing and siding to accommodate interior renovations. c) Certificate of Appropriateness Environmental Land Managers, LLC - Applicant 2019-0110 CHW LLC et al and 1 King Street LLC – Owner 1 King Street (a.k.a. 8 Marine Street) To replace existing concrete and coquina concrete walkways and non-paved areas with clay brick pavers in the front and rear building patio areas.
Continued Items from the previous HARB meetings Certificate of Appropriateness John and Karin White – Applicant and Owner 2019-0087 253 Charlotte Street (Continued from September Meeting) To replace all of the existing windows with vinyl windows.
Certificate of Demolition 2019-0106 Robin Bunnell – Applicant and Owner 107 Zoratoa Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1952 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and not located in a district. (Hurricane Damage)
2019-0108 St. Johns Housing Partnership, Inc. – Applicant and Owner 111 Masters Drive To demolish a building constructed in 1948 that is not recorded in the Florida Master Site File and not located in a district.
2019-0112 City of St. Augustine Public Works – Applicant City of St. Augustine – Owner Cuna Street section between Charlotte Street and Avenida Menendez To construct roadway improvements to match previously approved Downtown Improvement District design standards including coquina concrete and clay paving materials, light poles, string lights, street furniture, and removable fences and bollards.
Incomplete Items (At the time of application the package was not substantially complete) Certificate of Appropriateness Cronk Duch Architecture – Applicant 2019-0111 12 Avenida Menendez, LLC – Owner 12 Avenida Menendez To demolish rear portions of the building and property features, construct an attached one story loggia and rear one story buildings, construct an attached one story building to the south with roof patio area, add an upper patio to the existing building, and to alter or construct other associated features within the existing building and site area. (Building elevations were not provided at the application deadline and may have been submitted at a later time)
2019-0103 City of St. Augustine Public Works – Applicant City of St. Augustine – Owner Avenida Menendez and Marine Street intersection To construct pedestrian improvements across Avenida Menendez and Marine Street from Artillery Lane to the City Marina to include a crosswalk, signage, ADA ramp, and curbed islands.
12. Other Business a) Review schedule for 2020 proposed HARB meetings 13. Adjournment
Nov 21, 2019 Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB)
Roll Call
Special Presentation to conclude at 1:00 p.m.* a) Introduction of the consulting team for “Resilient Heritage in the Nation’s Oldest City” grant to include discussion and public comment
Approval of Minutes
Modification and approval of Agenda
Recommended Expedited Hearing Items a) Certificate of Appropriateness Paul J. Thompson – Applicant and Owner 2019-0104 168 Avenida Menendez To construct a 5’ masonry and stucco property wall with wood gate and relocate existing fencing to the second floor balcony. b) Certificate of Appropriateness John Valdes and Associates, Inc. - Applicant 2019-0107 Gary and Laura Shivers – Owner 101 Marine Street To alter a portion of the rear, northeast corner of the building’s first floor to include windows, doors, roofing and siding to accommodate interior renovations. c) Certificate of Appropriateness Environmental Land Managers, LLC - Applicant 2019-0110 CHW LLC et al and 1 King Street LLC – Owner 1 King Street (a.k.a. 8 Marine Street) To replace existing concrete and coquina concrete walkways and non-paved areas with clay brick pavers in the front and rear building patio areas.
Continued Items from the previous HARB meetings Certificate of Appropriateness John and Karin White – Applicant and Owner 2019-0087 253 Charlotte Street (Continued from September Meeting) To replace all of the existing windows with vinyl windows.
Certificate of Demolition 2019-0106 Robin Bunnell – Applicant and Owner 107 Zoratoa Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1952 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and not located in a district. (Hurricane Damage)
2019-0108 St. Johns Housing Partnership, Inc. – Applicant and Owner 111 Masters Drive To demolish a building constructed in 1948 that is not recorded in the Florida Master Site File and not located in a district.
2019-0112 City of St. Augustine Public Works – Applicant City of St. Augustine – Owner Cuna Street section between Charlotte Street and Avenida Menendez To construct roadway improvements to match previously approved Downtown Improvement District design standards including coquina concrete and clay paving materials, light poles, string lights, street furniture, and removable fences and bollards.
Incomplete Items (At the time of application the package was not substantially complete) Certificate of Appropriateness Cronk Duch Architecture – Applicant 2019-0111 12 Avenida Menendez, LLC – Owner 12 Avenida Menendez To demolish rear portions of the building and property features, construct an attached one story loggia and rear one story buildings, construct an attached one story building to the south with roof patio area, add an upper patio to the existing building, and to alter or construct other associated features within the existing building and site area. (Building elevations were not provided at the application deadline and may have been submitted at a later time)
2019-0103 City of St. Augustine Public Works – Applicant City of St. Augustine – Owner Avenida Menendez and Marine Street intersection To construct pedestrian improvements across Avenida Menendez and Marine Street from Artillery Lane to the City Marina to include a crosswalk, signage, ADA ramp, and curbed islands.
12. Other Business a) Review schedule for 2020 proposed HARB meetings 13. Adjournment