Roll Call
General Public Comments for Items not on the Agenda
Approval of Minutes
Modification and approval of Agenda
Certificate of Appropriateness Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicants 2018-0107 18 St. George Street LLC – Owner 18 St. George Street To construct new buildings between Spanish and St. George Streets designed with Spanish Colonial character
Certificate of Demolition Ronald L. Bailey Jr. – Applicant and Owner 2018-0104 101 South Street To demolish a building constructed in 1954 that does not contribute to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District and that is not listed in the Florida Master Site File.
Preliminary Design Approval for the Design Standards for Entry Corridors 2018-0082 Hagos Fissehaye – Applicant & Owner 3150 N. Ponce de Leon Blvd To review new construction and site development for conformance with Mixed Residential and Commercial Typology.
Opinion of Appropriateness City of St. Augustine – Owner and Applicant 2018-0111 20 Spanish Street To make alterations to an existing parking lot to include adding landscaping, constructing a masonry wall, and installing paving material, lighting, and signage.
Certificate of Appropriateness 2018-0119 Les Thomas – Applicant Historic Fraser Properties – Owner 14 St. George Street (Parcel ID: 197290 0000) To make alterations to a previously approved Certificate of Appropriateness to include adding fences, pavers, and a walkway; altering the configuration of the buildings on the property; and altering design elements and size of the buildings.
2018-0120 Les Thomas – Applicant OSH Property LLC – Owner 14 St. George Street (Parcel ID: 197291 0000) To construct a new one-story building with side gables and horizontal wood siding.
2018-0121 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicants Steven and Linda Lohrke – Owners 320 Charlotte Street To construct a second-story onto an existing one-story Frame Vernacular home and to build a two-story garage apartment.
2018-0123 Paul Thompson – Applicant and Owner 168 Avenida Menendez To remove six rear windows, four front windows, and a rear door and replace them with two garage doors, two sets of French doors, and a single door; to replace remaining windows with new windows; and to raise the height of the front porch wall to allow for a second story porch.
2018-0122 Paul Thompson – Owner and Applicant 168 Avenida Menendez To remove thirteen windows and two doors and fill in the openings with stucco.
Incomplete Hearing Items 2018-0117 Pete Peaver – Applicant Pete and Jan Peaver – Owner 19 Rohde Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1904 that is a contributing building to the North City Historic District and is listed on the Florida Master Site File. An Inspection Letter was provided for the property but upon further review, it was determined not to be sufficient due to no substantiating details or photographs. There was also no information provided about the engineer’s experience.
2018-0118 Charles M. Sapp and Emily S. Pugh – Applicants and Owners 160 Oneida Street To demolish a building constructed in 1894 that is a contributing building to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District and that is listed on the Florida Master Site File. Materials required for contributing buildings were not provided, including a condition assessment report
10. Other Business (approximately 5:30) a) Discuss and provide recommendation for the Historic Preservation Master Plan. This item will be taken up after a recess to allow the City Commission to conduct a required budget hearing and will not begin prior to 5:30. 12. Adjournment
Sep 20, 2018 Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB)
Roll Call
General Public Comments for Items not on the Agenda
Approval of Minutes
Modification and approval of Agenda
Certificate of Appropriateness Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicants 2018-0107 18 St. George Street LLC – Owner 18 St. George Street To construct new buildings between Spanish and St. George Streets designed with Spanish Colonial character
Certificate of Demolition Ronald L. Bailey Jr. – Applicant and Owner 2018-0104 101 South Street To demolish a building constructed in 1954 that does not contribute to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District and that is not listed in the Florida Master Site File.
Preliminary Design Approval for the Design Standards for Entry Corridors 2018-0082 Hagos Fissehaye – Applicant & Owner 3150 N. Ponce de Leon Blvd To review new construction and site development for conformance with Mixed Residential and Commercial Typology.
Opinion of Appropriateness City of St. Augustine – Owner and Applicant 2018-0111 20 Spanish Street To make alterations to an existing parking lot to include adding landscaping, constructing a masonry wall, and installing paving material, lighting, and signage.
Certificate of Appropriateness 2018-0119 Les Thomas – Applicant Historic Fraser Properties – Owner 14 St. George Street (Parcel ID: 197290 0000) To make alterations to a previously approved Certificate of Appropriateness to include adding fences, pavers, and a walkway; altering the configuration of the buildings on the property; and altering design elements and size of the buildings.
2018-0120 Les Thomas – Applicant OSH Property LLC – Owner 14 St. George Street (Parcel ID: 197291 0000) To construct a new one-story building with side gables and horizontal wood siding.
2018-0121 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicants Steven and Linda Lohrke – Owners 320 Charlotte Street To construct a second-story onto an existing one-story Frame Vernacular home and to build a two-story garage apartment.
2018-0123 Paul Thompson – Applicant and Owner 168 Avenida Menendez To remove six rear windows, four front windows, and a rear door and replace them with two garage doors, two sets of French doors, and a single door; to replace remaining windows with new windows; and to raise the height of the front porch wall to allow for a second story porch.
2018-0122 Paul Thompson – Owner and Applicant 168 Avenida Menendez To remove thirteen windows and two doors and fill in the openings with stucco.
Incomplete Hearing Items 2018-0117 Pete Peaver – Applicant Pete and Jan Peaver – Owner 19 Rohde Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1904 that is a contributing building to the North City Historic District and is listed on the Florida Master Site File. An Inspection Letter was provided for the property but upon further review, it was determined not to be sufficient due to no substantiating details or photographs. There was also no information provided about the engineer’s experience.
2018-0118 Charles M. Sapp and Emily S. Pugh – Applicants and Owners 160 Oneida Street To demolish a building constructed in 1894 that is a contributing building to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District and that is listed on the Florida Master Site File. Materials required for contributing buildings were not provided, including a condition assessment report
10. Other Business (approximately 5:30) a) Discuss and provide recommendation for the Historic Preservation Master Plan. This item will be taken up after a recess to allow the City Commission to conduct a required budget hearing and will not begin prior to 5:30. 12. Adjournment