Roll Call
General Public Comments for Items not on the Agenda
Public Comments related to Expedited Hearing items: a) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0164 Catch 27 Restaurant LLC – Applicant 46 Avenida Menendez, Inc. – Owner 40 Charlotte Street To add a handicap accessibility ramp, convert a window to a door, construct a stucco covered chimney to screen the exhaust system, and construct a wood fence and gate to screen equipment. b) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0168 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant Cordova Properties LLC – Owner 39 and 41 Cordova Street To install awnings along the front of the buildings and conduct maintenance and repair to doors and planters. c) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0159 Triad Service Group – Applicant Sisters of St. Joseph – Owner 234 St. George Street/PID 199480 0000 To improve the existing parking lot with coquina and brick paved areas, on-site drainage, light fixtures, and landscape materials. d) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0157 BEHST Builders, Inc. – Applicant Anastasia’s On the Bay, LLC – Owner 105 Marine Street To improve the existing two driveways with coquina concrete and gravel and improve stormwater drainage. Historic Architectural Review Board HARB Agenda November 19, 2015 2 e) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0158 Kanti Patel – Applicant San Marco Hotel, Inc. – Owner 6 Castillo Drive To add two porches, two dormers, and a door to previously approved plans for a hotel. f) Certificate of Demolition (Partial) F2015-0165 Gray 1908 – Applicant Annie Jensen – Owner 73 San Marco Avenue To remove rear additions on a building constructed ca. 1917 and contributing to the Abbott Tract National Register Historic District. (Associated with proposed plans for an addition reviewed as a Preliminary Design Approval) g) Certificate of Demolition (Partial) F2015-0163 Ancient City Construction, Inc. – Applicant Benoit Therrien – Owner 98 Bridge Street To remove rear additions on a building constructed ca. 1894 and contributing to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District.
Approval of Minutes (including minutes of 10/29/15 DSEC meeting if applicable)
Modification and approval of Agenda
Continued Items from previous meeting(s): Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0079 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant Marion Hart and Mary Shannon Hart – Owner 251 Charlotte Street (August) To remove siding, remove front porch and construct a two story porch, add second floor door, alter windows on upper enclosed porch and rear access stair, and construct a pergola.
Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0094 Wendy Relph – Applicant and Owner 23 Cuna Street (August) To construct a free standing wood structure with a flat metal roof in the rear yard area.
Certificate of Demolition F2015-0141 Cronk Duch Architects – Applicant White’s Wharf LLC – Owner (October) 135 Avenida Menendez To demolish a contributing building to the St. Augustine National Register Historic District built between 1910 and 1917. See proposed replacement building with application for an Opinion of Appropriateness F2015-0138.
Opinion of Appropriateness F2015-0138 Cronk Duch Architects – Applicant White’s Wharf LLC – Owner (October) 135 Avenida Menendez To construct a replacement building for the existing restaurant characterized by a grouping of buildings with shingle-covered, gable roof systems and shed dormers, a covered wrap-around porch, and two detached hipped roof structures. The building faces the HP-2 zoning district and the visible facades to the historic district must be found to be reasonably compatible.
Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0145 WCI Group, Inc. - Applicant Richard and Ann Marie LaVista – Owner 315 St. George Street To install an aluminum patio cover over the existing wood deck attached to the rear of the building.
g) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0146 Marquis Halback, Inc. and Don Crichlow – Applicant Old Island Hotels, Inc. – Owner Multiple Addresses/PID 199490 (143 Cordova St) To rehabilitate a perimeter wall on Cordova Street and conduct site and landscape alterations throughout the property. (Some items from this application were approved in October and have been deleted from the project description) 7. Certificate of Appropriateness for Ad Valorem Tax Exemption a) F2015-0169 Old Island Hotels, Inc. – Applicant and Owner Multiple Addresses/PID 199490 (143 Cordova St) To review plans for building rehabilitations at 244, 246, and 250 St. George Street for an ad valorem tax exemption application.
Certificates of Demolition a) F2015-0155 Ponce Hotel, Inc. – Applicant and Owner 16 Garnett Avenue To demolish a building constructed circa 1924 and not located in a historic district.
F2015-0156 Custom Homes of St. Augustine – Applicant William Brown and Gail Wisler – Owner 163 Martin Luther King Avenue To demolish a building constructed circa 1930 and contributing building to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District.
F2015-0161 L. Mariotti Construction – Applicant Broudy Bros, LTD - Owner 198 West King Street To demolish a building constructed circa 1945 and not located in a historic district.
Applications related to the Design Standards for Entry Corridors: a) Preliminary Design Approval F2015-0136 A.D. Davis Construction – Applicant S & Y Investments, Inc. – Owner 283 San Marco Avenue To review a proposed design in accordance with the Traditional Commercial typology of the Design Standards for Entry Corridors that includes adding to the existing building footprint of a one story stucco building and adding a second floor. Due to advertising error this project requires another hearing.
Preliminary Design Approval F2015-0147 Augustine Development Group, LLC – Continued from Applicant and Owner 10/29/15 215 Anastasia Boulevard To review a proposed design in accordance with the Highway Commercial typology of the Design Standards for Entry Corridors that includes building construction on a vacant lot with ground level parking and two stories above the parking facility.
Variance F2015-0160 Thomas Rochelle – Applicant Karen and Thomas Rochelle – Owner 104 Anastasia Boulevard To request a variance to the Design Standards for Entry Corridors to paint murals on the building.
Preliminary Design Approval F2015-0166 Gray 1908 – Applicant Annie Jensen – Owner 73 San Marco Avenue To review the design of proposed alterations to the primary building and construction of an accessory structure for conformance with the Mixed Residential and Commercial typology. (See also partial demolition application F2015-0165)
Preliminary Design Approval and Amendment to Assigned Typology F2015-0162 Rogers Towers, P.A. – Applicant Flagler College, Inc. – Owner 1 Malaga Street To request a change in the assigned typology from Traditional Commercial to Institutional including a Preliminary Design Review for construction of student housing and a parking garage.
Preliminary Design Approval F2015-0167 Gulfstream Design Group, St. Johns Law Group, Marquis Halback, Inc., and Ormond Land Development LLC – Applicants Frank Hunter, Kathryn Hynum, and Jasper and Kathleen Wynn – Owners SE Corner of King and Prawn Street (PID 119650 0000 and 119660 0000) To review the design of a proposed hotel for conformance with the Traditional Commercial typology on the King Street Corridor for a Preliminary Design Approval.
10. Other Business a) Discussion regarding public notice for applications 11. Review of Conflict Statements from Previous Meetings 12. Adjournment
Nov 19, 2015 Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB)
Roll Call
General Public Comments for Items not on the Agenda
Public Comments related to Expedited Hearing items: a) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0164 Catch 27 Restaurant LLC – Applicant 46 Avenida Menendez, Inc. – Owner 40 Charlotte Street To add a handicap accessibility ramp, convert a window to a door, construct a stucco covered chimney to screen the exhaust system, and construct a wood fence and gate to screen equipment. b) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0168 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant Cordova Properties LLC – Owner 39 and 41 Cordova Street To install awnings along the front of the buildings and conduct maintenance and repair to doors and planters. c) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0159 Triad Service Group – Applicant Sisters of St. Joseph – Owner 234 St. George Street/PID 199480 0000 To improve the existing parking lot with coquina and brick paved areas, on-site drainage, light fixtures, and landscape materials. d) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0157 BEHST Builders, Inc. – Applicant Anastasia’s On the Bay, LLC – Owner 105 Marine Street To improve the existing two driveways with coquina concrete and gravel and improve stormwater drainage. Historic Architectural Review Board HARB Agenda November 19, 2015 2 e) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0158 Kanti Patel – Applicant San Marco Hotel, Inc. – Owner 6 Castillo Drive To add two porches, two dormers, and a door to previously approved plans for a hotel. f) Certificate of Demolition (Partial) F2015-0165 Gray 1908 – Applicant Annie Jensen – Owner 73 San Marco Avenue To remove rear additions on a building constructed ca. 1917 and contributing to the Abbott Tract National Register Historic District. (Associated with proposed plans for an addition reviewed as a Preliminary Design Approval) g) Certificate of Demolition (Partial) F2015-0163 Ancient City Construction, Inc. – Applicant Benoit Therrien – Owner 98 Bridge Street To remove rear additions on a building constructed ca. 1894 and contributing to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District.
Approval of Minutes (including minutes of 10/29/15 DSEC meeting if applicable)
Modification and approval of Agenda
Continued Items from previous meeting(s): Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0079 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant Marion Hart and Mary Shannon Hart – Owner 251 Charlotte Street (August) To remove siding, remove front porch and construct a two story porch, add second floor door, alter windows on upper enclosed porch and rear access stair, and construct a pergola.
Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0094 Wendy Relph – Applicant and Owner 23 Cuna Street (August) To construct a free standing wood structure with a flat metal roof in the rear yard area.
Certificate of Demolition F2015-0141 Cronk Duch Architects – Applicant White’s Wharf LLC – Owner (October) 135 Avenida Menendez To demolish a contributing building to the St. Augustine National Register Historic District built between 1910 and 1917. See proposed replacement building with application for an Opinion of Appropriateness F2015-0138.
Opinion of Appropriateness F2015-0138 Cronk Duch Architects – Applicant White’s Wharf LLC – Owner (October) 135 Avenida Menendez To construct a replacement building for the existing restaurant characterized by a grouping of buildings with shingle-covered, gable roof systems and shed dormers, a covered wrap-around porch, and two detached hipped roof structures. The building faces the HP-2 zoning district and the visible facades to the historic district must be found to be reasonably compatible.
Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0145 WCI Group, Inc. - Applicant Richard and Ann Marie LaVista – Owner 315 St. George Street To install an aluminum patio cover over the existing wood deck attached to the rear of the building.
g) Certificate of Appropriateness F2015-0146 Marquis Halback, Inc. and Don Crichlow – Applicant Old Island Hotels, Inc. – Owner Multiple Addresses/PID 199490 (143 Cordova St) To rehabilitate a perimeter wall on Cordova Street and conduct site and landscape alterations throughout the property. (Some items from this application were approved in October and have been deleted from the project description) 7. Certificate of Appropriateness for Ad Valorem Tax Exemption a) F2015-0169 Old Island Hotels, Inc. – Applicant and Owner Multiple Addresses/PID 199490 (143 Cordova St) To review plans for building rehabilitations at 244, 246, and 250 St. George Street for an ad valorem tax exemption application.
Certificates of Demolition a) F2015-0155 Ponce Hotel, Inc. – Applicant and Owner 16 Garnett Avenue To demolish a building constructed circa 1924 and not located in a historic district.
F2015-0156 Custom Homes of St. Augustine – Applicant William Brown and Gail Wisler – Owner 163 Martin Luther King Avenue To demolish a building constructed circa 1930 and contributing building to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District.
F2015-0161 L. Mariotti Construction – Applicant Broudy Bros, LTD - Owner 198 West King Street To demolish a building constructed circa 1945 and not located in a historic district.
Applications related to the Design Standards for Entry Corridors: a) Preliminary Design Approval F2015-0136 A.D. Davis Construction – Applicant S & Y Investments, Inc. – Owner 283 San Marco Avenue To review a proposed design in accordance with the Traditional Commercial typology of the Design Standards for Entry Corridors that includes adding to the existing building footprint of a one story stucco building and adding a second floor. Due to advertising error this project requires another hearing.
Preliminary Design Approval F2015-0147 Augustine Development Group, LLC – Continued from Applicant and Owner 10/29/15 215 Anastasia Boulevard To review a proposed design in accordance with the Highway Commercial typology of the Design Standards for Entry Corridors that includes building construction on a vacant lot with ground level parking and two stories above the parking facility.
Variance F2015-0160 Thomas Rochelle – Applicant Karen and Thomas Rochelle – Owner 104 Anastasia Boulevard To request a variance to the Design Standards for Entry Corridors to paint murals on the building.
Preliminary Design Approval F2015-0166 Gray 1908 – Applicant Annie Jensen – Owner 73 San Marco Avenue To review the design of proposed alterations to the primary building and construction of an accessory structure for conformance with the Mixed Residential and Commercial typology. (See also partial demolition application F2015-0165)
Preliminary Design Approval and Amendment to Assigned Typology F2015-0162 Rogers Towers, P.A. – Applicant Flagler College, Inc. – Owner 1 Malaga Street To request a change in the assigned typology from Traditional Commercial to Institutional including a Preliminary Design Review for construction of student housing and a parking garage.
Preliminary Design Approval F2015-0167 Gulfstream Design Group, St. Johns Law Group, Marquis Halback, Inc., and Ormond Land Development LLC – Applicants Frank Hunter, Kathryn Hynum, and Jasper and Kathleen Wynn – Owners SE Corner of King and Prawn Street (PID 119650 0000 and 119660 0000) To review the design of a proposed hotel for conformance with the Traditional Commercial typology on the King Street Corridor for a Preliminary Design Approval.
10. Other Business a) Discussion regarding public notice for applications 11. Review of Conflict Statements from Previous Meetings 12. Adjournment