Roll Call
General Public Comments for Items not on the Agenda
Modification and approval of Agenda
Recommended Expedited Hearing Items* Certificate of Appropriateness A to Z Custom Homes, Inc. – Applicant 2018-0147 Harold E. Fethe and Frances G. Charlson – Owner 71 Marine Street To replace a copper metal roof with a coated aluminum roof in a medium bronze finish.
Certificate of Appropriateness Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicants 2018-0121 Steven and Linda Lohrke – Owners (Continued from September 20, 2018) 320 Charlotte Street To construct a second-story onto an existing one-story Frame Vernacular home and to build a two-story garage apartment.
Certificate of Appropriateness a) 2018-0134 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicant 18 St. George Street LLC – Owner 18 St. George Street To construct new buildings between Spanish and St. George Streets designed with Spanish Colonial character.
Certificate of Demolition 2018-0143 James Philcox – Owner and Applicant 111 Zoratoa Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1922 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
2018-0144 Sarah Ryan, Architect - Applicant Dave and Lynn McKee - Owners 329 St. George Street Partial demolition of a building constructed in 1910, recorded in the Florida Master Site file, and not located in a district to include the windows, roof, and chimney.
2018-0135 R.L. Bailey – Owner and Applicant 101 South Street To demolish a building constructed in 1954 that does not contribute to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District and that is not recorded in the Florida Master Site File.
2018-0139 Steven Binninger – Applicant Green Family Investment LTD – Owner 55 Masters Drive To demolish a building constructed in 1910 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
2018-0140 Shawn and Renee Aunchman – Owner and Applicant 478 Arricola Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1955 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
f) 2018-0141 Muscetta Custom – Applicant BETA Three of Alachua LLC – Owner 28 Magnolia Avenue Partial demolition of a building constructed in 1917 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and not located in a National Register District to include removal of windows, doors, exterior walls, and a portion of the roof (after-the-fact). g) 2018-0149 BETA Three of Alachua LLC– Applicant and Owner 28 ½ Magnolia Avenue To demolish a guest house constructed in 1935 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
Appeal of Staff Interpretation of the Design Standards for Entry Corridors a) 2018-0146 Antigua Veterinary Practice – Applicant Eric Searcy Rentals LLC - Owner 195 San Marco Avenue To appeal the staff interpretation of the Design Standards that a metal roof is not a compatible replacement roof material to maintain the character of the legacy building as per 6.4.1.c.
Incomplete Items a) Certificate of Appropriateness Martin Gould - Applicant 2018-0145 EMA Inc. - Owner 36 Charlotte Street To construct a trellis over the front seating area and to convert the front fence into a wall. *Need Owners Signature*
Preliminary Design Approval for the Design Standards for Entry Corridors a) 2018-0148 City of St. Augustine Police Department Applicant, City of St. Augustine – Owner 151 King Street To install color LED lighting on the exterior of the building.
Other Business a) Selection of Chair & Vice-Chair for Fiscal Year 2018-2019 b) Review annual meeting schedule
13. Review of Conflict Statements from Previous Meetings 14. Adjournment
Nov 15, 2018 Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB)
Roll Call
General Public Comments for Items not on the Agenda
Modification and approval of Agenda
Recommended Expedited Hearing Items* Certificate of Appropriateness A to Z Custom Homes, Inc. – Applicant 2018-0147 Harold E. Fethe and Frances G. Charlson – Owner 71 Marine Street To replace a copper metal roof with a coated aluminum roof in a medium bronze finish.
Certificate of Appropriateness Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicants 2018-0121 Steven and Linda Lohrke – Owners (Continued from September 20, 2018) 320 Charlotte Street To construct a second-story onto an existing one-story Frame Vernacular home and to build a two-story garage apartment.
Certificate of Appropriateness a) 2018-0134 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicant 18 St. George Street LLC – Owner 18 St. George Street To construct new buildings between Spanish and St. George Streets designed with Spanish Colonial character.
Certificate of Demolition 2018-0143 James Philcox – Owner and Applicant 111 Zoratoa Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1922 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
2018-0144 Sarah Ryan, Architect - Applicant Dave and Lynn McKee - Owners 329 St. George Street Partial demolition of a building constructed in 1910, recorded in the Florida Master Site file, and not located in a district to include the windows, roof, and chimney.
2018-0135 R.L. Bailey – Owner and Applicant 101 South Street To demolish a building constructed in 1954 that does not contribute to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District and that is not recorded in the Florida Master Site File.
2018-0139 Steven Binninger – Applicant Green Family Investment LTD – Owner 55 Masters Drive To demolish a building constructed in 1910 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
2018-0140 Shawn and Renee Aunchman – Owner and Applicant 478 Arricola Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1955 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
f) 2018-0141 Muscetta Custom – Applicant BETA Three of Alachua LLC – Owner 28 Magnolia Avenue Partial demolition of a building constructed in 1917 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and not located in a National Register District to include removal of windows, doors, exterior walls, and a portion of the roof (after-the-fact). g) 2018-0149 BETA Three of Alachua LLC– Applicant and Owner 28 ½ Magnolia Avenue To demolish a guest house constructed in 1935 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
Appeal of Staff Interpretation of the Design Standards for Entry Corridors a) 2018-0146 Antigua Veterinary Practice – Applicant Eric Searcy Rentals LLC - Owner 195 San Marco Avenue To appeal the staff interpretation of the Design Standards that a metal roof is not a compatible replacement roof material to maintain the character of the legacy building as per 6.4.1.c.
Incomplete Items a) Certificate of Appropriateness Martin Gould - Applicant 2018-0145 EMA Inc. - Owner 36 Charlotte Street To construct a trellis over the front seating area and to convert the front fence into a wall. *Need Owners Signature*
Preliminary Design Approval for the Design Standards for Entry Corridors a) 2018-0148 City of St. Augustine Police Department Applicant, City of St. Augustine – Owner 151 King Street To install color LED lighting on the exterior of the building.
Other Business a) Selection of Chair & Vice-Chair for Fiscal Year 2018-2019 b) Review annual meeting schedule
13. Review of Conflict Statements from Previous Meetings 14. Adjournment