Recommended Expedited Hearing Items* Certificate of Appropriateness A to Z Custom Homes, Inc. – Applicant 2018-0147 Harold E. Fethe and Frances G. Charlson – Owner 71 Marine Street To replace a copper metal roof with a coated aluminum roof in a medium bronze finish.
Certificate of Appropriateness Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicants 2018-0121 Steven and Linda Lohrke – Owners (Continued from September 20, 2018) 320 Charlotte Street To construct a second-story onto an existing one-story Frame Vernacular home and to build a two-story garage apartment.
Certificate of Appropriateness a) 2018-0134 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicant 18 St. George Street LLC – Owner 18 St. George Street To construct new buildings between Spanish and St. George Streets designed with Spanish Colonial character.
Certificate of Demolition 2018-0143 James Philcox – Owner and Applicant 111 Zoratoa Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1922 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
2018-0144 Sarah Ryan, Architect - Applicant Dave and Lynn McKee - Owners 329 St. George Street Partial demolition of a building constructed in 1910, recorded in the Florida Master Site file, and not located in a district to include the windows, roof, and chimney.
2018-0135 R.L. Bailey – Owner and Applicant 101 South Street To demolish a building constructed in 1954 that does not contribute to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District and that is not recorded in the Florida Master Site File.
2018-0139 Steven Binninger – Applicant Green Family Investment LTD – Owner 55 Masters Drive To demolish a building constructed in 1910 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
2018-0140 Shawn and Renee Aunchman – Owner and Applicant 478 Arricola Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1955 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
f) 2018-0141 Muscetta Custom – Applicant BETA Three of Alachua LLC – Owner 28 Magnolia Avenue Partial demolition of a building constructed in 1917 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and not located in a National Register District to include removal of windows, doors, exterior walls, and a portion of the roof (after-the-fact). g) 2018-0149 BETA Three of Alachua LLC– Applicant and Owner 28 ½ Magnolia Avenue To demolish a guest house constructed in 1935 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
Appeal of Staff Interpretation of the Design Standards for Entry Corridors a) 2018-0146 Antigua Veterinary Practice – Applicant Eric Searcy Rentals LLC - Owner 195 San Marco Avenue To appeal the staff interpretation of the Design Standards that a metal roof is not a compatible replacement roof material to maintain the character of the legacy building as per 6.4.1.c.
Incomplete Items a) Certificate of Appropriateness Martin Gould - Applicant 2018-0145 EMA Inc. - Owner 36 Charlotte Street To construct a trellis over the front seating area and to convert the front fence into a wall. *Need Owners Signature*
Preliminary Design Approval for the Design Standards for Entry Corridors a) 2018-0148 City of St. Augustine Police Department Applicant, City of St. Augustine – Owner 151 King Street To install color LED lighting on the exterior of the building.
Other Business a) Selection of Chair & Vice-Chair for Fiscal Year 2018-2019 b) Review annual meeting schedule
Nov 15, 2018 Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB)
Recommended Expedited Hearing Items* Certificate of Appropriateness A to Z Custom Homes, Inc. – Applicant 2018-0147 Harold E. Fethe and Frances G. Charlson – Owner 71 Marine Street To replace a copper metal roof with a coated aluminum roof in a medium bronze finish.
Certificate of Appropriateness Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicants 2018-0121 Steven and Linda Lohrke – Owners (Continued from September 20, 2018) 320 Charlotte Street To construct a second-story onto an existing one-story Frame Vernacular home and to build a two-story garage apartment.
Certificate of Appropriateness a) 2018-0134 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicant 18 St. George Street LLC – Owner 18 St. George Street To construct new buildings between Spanish and St. George Streets designed with Spanish Colonial character.
Certificate of Demolition 2018-0143 James Philcox – Owner and Applicant 111 Zoratoa Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1922 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
2018-0144 Sarah Ryan, Architect - Applicant Dave and Lynn McKee - Owners 329 St. George Street Partial demolition of a building constructed in 1910, recorded in the Florida Master Site file, and not located in a district to include the windows, roof, and chimney.
2018-0135 R.L. Bailey – Owner and Applicant 101 South Street To demolish a building constructed in 1954 that does not contribute to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District and that is not recorded in the Florida Master Site File.
2018-0139 Steven Binninger – Applicant Green Family Investment LTD – Owner 55 Masters Drive To demolish a building constructed in 1910 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
2018-0140 Shawn and Renee Aunchman – Owner and Applicant 478 Arricola Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1955 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
f) 2018-0141 Muscetta Custom – Applicant BETA Three of Alachua LLC – Owner 28 Magnolia Avenue Partial demolition of a building constructed in 1917 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and not located in a National Register District to include removal of windows, doors, exterior walls, and a portion of the roof (after-the-fact). g) 2018-0149 BETA Three of Alachua LLC– Applicant and Owner 28 ½ Magnolia Avenue To demolish a guest house constructed in 1935 that is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and is not located in a National Register Historic District.
Appeal of Staff Interpretation of the Design Standards for Entry Corridors a) 2018-0146 Antigua Veterinary Practice – Applicant Eric Searcy Rentals LLC - Owner 195 San Marco Avenue To appeal the staff interpretation of the Design Standards that a metal roof is not a compatible replacement roof material to maintain the character of the legacy building as per 6.4.1.c.
Incomplete Items a) Certificate of Appropriateness Martin Gould - Applicant 2018-0145 EMA Inc. - Owner 36 Charlotte Street To construct a trellis over the front seating area and to convert the front fence into a wall. *Need Owners Signature*
Preliminary Design Approval for the Design Standards for Entry Corridors a) 2018-0148 City of St. Augustine Police Department Applicant, City of St. Augustine – Owner 151 King Street To install color LED lighting on the exterior of the building.
Other Business a) Selection of Chair & Vice-Chair for Fiscal Year 2018-2019 b) Review annual meeting schedule