Roll Call
Modification and approval of Agenda
Approval of Minutes a) Draft minutes from June 18, 2020 HARB CMT meeting
F2020-0052 Certificate of Appropriateness Paul Thompson – Applicant Paul Thompson and Maxie Thompson – Owner 67 Marine Street To elevate the building following the concept design approved in the 2017 Opinion of Appropriateness including a new first floor finished with stucco, new doors and garage door, window, balcony, driveway, and removal of non-historic property walls.
F2020-0053 Certificate of Partial Demolition Paul Thompson – Applicant Paul Thompson and Maxie Thompson – Owner 67 Marine Street To partially demolish a structure built ca. 1840 and contributing to the St. Augustine Historic District limited to the chimney.
F2020-0073 TTV Architects, Inc. – Applicant University of Florida Historic St. Augustine, Inc. – Owner 46 Cuna Street To modify the existing coquina warehouse with a new opening, exterior wood staircase, four wall exhaust vents, lighting, ADA compliant ramps, and site features.
F2020-0069 Geraldine and Peter Vaccaro – Applicant Peter Vaccaro and Geraldine Nowak – Owner 15 Bridge Street After the fact approval to replace gate and framing using design approved in 2006, with colors and hardware finish that are not preapproved.
c) F2020-0065 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicant Scott and Nikki Gordon – Owner 287 St. George Street To build 48" high masonry wall along front and partial north property line to create a flood barrier and to construct a 48" high wood picket fence in front of masonry wall. (See also F2020-0066 and F2020-0067) d) F2020-0066 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicant Patrick Crocetta – Owner 289 St. George Street To build 48" high masonry wall along front property line to create a flood barrier and to construct a 48" high wood picket fence in front of masonry wall. (See also F2020-0065 and F2020-0067) e) F2020-0067 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicant Maria Celia Pellecer – Owner 295 St. George Street To build 48" high masonry wall along front and partial south property line to create a flood barrier. (See also F2020-0065 and F2020-0066)
F2020-0071 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant David and Elizabeth Powell – Owner 43 Cordova Street To construct a detached carport in the rear courtyard.
F2020-0074 Marquis Latimer + Halback, Inc. – Applicant 46 Avenida Menendez, Inc. – Owner 46 Charlotte Street To make changes that include ADA accessibility to front and rear porches of building and site features including landscape features, displays, lighting, trellises, an outbuilding, and modifications to property wall
F2020-0076 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant James and Cole Wilson – Owner 272 St. George Street To partially demolish a building limited to the detached structure built ca. 1960-1970.
F2020-0070 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant James and Cole Wilson – Owner 272 St. George Street To construct a new garage to replace existing detached structure built ca. 1960-1970.
F2020-0072 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant Modesto Gómez and Heidi Sykes-Gómez – Owner 35 Magnolia Avenue To partially demolish a building, constructed ca. 1925 that is not located in a district but is recorded on the Florida Master Site File, including the garage addition (ca. 1950s).
F2020-0068 John and Sheryl Foti – Applicant and Owner 25 Miruela Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1964 and not located in a district but is recorded on the Florida Master Site File.
Certificate of Appropriateness – City owned property a) F2020-0075 Marquis Latimer + Halback, Inc. – Applicant City of St. Augustine – Owner Spanish Street (Cuna to Orange); Cuna Street (Cordova to Charlotte); Tolomato Lane To continue the Downtown Improvements District Phase 1, completed in 2015, with addition of new streetscape, landscape features, and street lights.
Planning and Building Staff Communications a) Planning and Building Staff Approved Permits Report
12. Other Business a) Discussion regarding a request from the FDOT for CLG review of design suggestions related to the SR 5A/King Street bridge over San Sebastian River (Bridge No 78003). 13. Adjournment
Jul 16, 2020 Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB)
Roll Call
Modification and approval of Agenda
Approval of Minutes a) Draft minutes from June 18, 2020 HARB CMT meeting
F2020-0052 Certificate of Appropriateness Paul Thompson – Applicant Paul Thompson and Maxie Thompson – Owner 67 Marine Street To elevate the building following the concept design approved in the 2017 Opinion of Appropriateness including a new first floor finished with stucco, new doors and garage door, window, balcony, driveway, and removal of non-historic property walls.
F2020-0053 Certificate of Partial Demolition Paul Thompson – Applicant Paul Thompson and Maxie Thompson – Owner 67 Marine Street To partially demolish a structure built ca. 1840 and contributing to the St. Augustine Historic District limited to the chimney.
F2020-0073 TTV Architects, Inc. – Applicant University of Florida Historic St. Augustine, Inc. – Owner 46 Cuna Street To modify the existing coquina warehouse with a new opening, exterior wood staircase, four wall exhaust vents, lighting, ADA compliant ramps, and site features.
F2020-0069 Geraldine and Peter Vaccaro – Applicant Peter Vaccaro and Geraldine Nowak – Owner 15 Bridge Street After the fact approval to replace gate and framing using design approved in 2006, with colors and hardware finish that are not preapproved.
c) F2020-0065 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicant Scott and Nikki Gordon – Owner 287 St. George Street To build 48" high masonry wall along front and partial north property line to create a flood barrier and to construct a 48" high wood picket fence in front of masonry wall. (See also F2020-0066 and F2020-0067) d) F2020-0066 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicant Patrick Crocetta – Owner 289 St. George Street To build 48" high masonry wall along front property line to create a flood barrier and to construct a 48" high wood picket fence in front of masonry wall. (See also F2020-0065 and F2020-0067) e) F2020-0067 Don Crichlow & Associates – Applicant Maria Celia Pellecer – Owner 295 St. George Street To build 48" high masonry wall along front and partial south property line to create a flood barrier. (See also F2020-0065 and F2020-0066)
F2020-0071 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant David and Elizabeth Powell – Owner 43 Cordova Street To construct a detached carport in the rear courtyard.
F2020-0074 Marquis Latimer + Halback, Inc. – Applicant 46 Avenida Menendez, Inc. – Owner 46 Charlotte Street To make changes that include ADA accessibility to front and rear porches of building and site features including landscape features, displays, lighting, trellises, an outbuilding, and modifications to property wall
F2020-0076 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant James and Cole Wilson – Owner 272 St. George Street To partially demolish a building limited to the detached structure built ca. 1960-1970.
F2020-0070 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant James and Cole Wilson – Owner 272 St. George Street To construct a new garage to replace existing detached structure built ca. 1960-1970.
F2020-0072 Les Thomas Architect – Applicant Modesto Gómez and Heidi Sykes-Gómez – Owner 35 Magnolia Avenue To partially demolish a building, constructed ca. 1925 that is not located in a district but is recorded on the Florida Master Site File, including the garage addition (ca. 1950s).
F2020-0068 John and Sheryl Foti – Applicant and Owner 25 Miruela Avenue To demolish a building constructed in 1964 and not located in a district but is recorded on the Florida Master Site File.
Certificate of Appropriateness – City owned property a) F2020-0075 Marquis Latimer + Halback, Inc. – Applicant City of St. Augustine – Owner Spanish Street (Cuna to Orange); Cuna Street (Cordova to Charlotte); Tolomato Lane To continue the Downtown Improvements District Phase 1, completed in 2015, with addition of new streetscape, landscape features, and street lights.
Planning and Building Staff Communications a) Planning and Building Staff Approved Permits Report
12. Other Business a) Discussion regarding a request from the FDOT for CLG review of design suggestions related to the SR 5A/King Street bridge over San Sebastian River (Bridge No 78003). 13. Adjournment